Murphy, Hesse, Toomey & Lehane Advisory Board Member Pens
United We Stand
MHTL’s advisory board member, Charles Desmond pens a powerful article on the recent protests.
Dr. Desmond is a former chair of the MA Board of Higher Education for eight years, recent recipient of the MLK Living Legacy Award from UMass Boston for his continued work of social justice and racial equality, recipient of the silver and bronze start for valor, and presently serves as the CEO of Inversant, the largest parent-centered children’s saving account initiative in the Commonwealth. Dr. Desmond was also featured in Tom Brokaw’s book “Boom”.
United We Stand
This is a uniquely defining moment in American history. In our collective lifetime, few of us have seen or could possibly imagine anything approaching the events we are now witnessing on the streets of Boston, across New England, and in states and countries across the globe. What began as low simmering protests in Minnesota has metastasized and sparked massive demonstrations, public unrest, civil disobedience and seemingly unending acts of public revolt in cities and towns across the nation and globe.
Universal feelings of disgust, anger and rage have erupted over the callous and dehumanizing murder of George Floyd, a black man whose gasping cries for air and helpless pleas for his mother went unheeded as a rogue white police officer knelt on his neck while three of his fellow officers stood by and watched Floyd’s life poured out on a Minneapolis street. The depravity and grizzly last moments of Floyd’s life were captured on a video reminiscent of the horrific Lorraine Motel assassination video of Martin Luther King some 52 years earlier.
Issues of entrenched, systemic and institutionalized racism have long been matters of great concern in America. The brutality of slavery led to the Civil War, Reconstruction and decades of dehumanizing racial oppression in America. The civil rights movement of the 1950s and 60s was a reaction to heightened racial segregation and oppression in the United States, and many people, myself included, believed the groundbreaking legislative and legal provisions enacted in the aftermath of that movement were destined to usher in a new, more open, egalitarian and just era in America.
While progress was undeniably made for many black and minority Americans in education, employment, housing and other areas of social advancements since the 60s’, deep and enduring remnants of racial injustice, police brutality and economic inequality remain in urban centers and rural pockets of the country. George Floyd’s death contemporized this reality in America, and people from all walks of life resonated with his suffering, identified with his humanity and grieved for his brutal death. In response, they joined together in a collective wave of action focused on advancing equality, racial justice and social change across the nation.
America now stands with the eyes of the world upon it. It is, in many ways, a moment of truth in which our country is again being tested to see how it will respond to yet another historic challenge to its system of government, the world’s oldest, continuously active codified constitution, predicated on equality and the unalienable belief that all men are created equal. In these challenging and uncertain times, I turn to Abraham Lincoln who said, “It is a sin to be silent when it is your duty to protest.”
Charles F. Desmond
Attorney Felicia Vasudevan, a partner at Murphy, Hesse, Toomey & Lehane, LLP, received a favorable decision on behalf of her client, Marshfield Public Schools. The Plaintiff appealed the district court’s judgement that upheld a decision of the Massachusetts Bureau of Special Education Appeals (“BSEA”). However, as the notice was filed more than 30 days after entry, the First Circuit ultimately dismissed the appeal for being untimely. The Plaintiff also appealed the district court’s order, denying her motion to vacate. Read More
Following our Alert from March 16, 2023, Civility is Dead – The Supreme Court Rules Municipal Control of Public Speak Limited to Reasonable Time/Place/Manner Restrictions, which discussed the holding to the Supreme Judicial Court’s decision in Barron v. Kolenda and the Town of Southborough (SJC-13284), we promised to bring you more detailed guidance on developing a Public Speak policy for your public body or municipality. The Barron case involved a constitutional challenge to the Town of Southborough’s public comment policy, which attempted to impose a code of civility on members of the public who participated in public comment before public bodies. In Barron, the court interpreted the state constitution to mean that public bodies may request, but not require, that public commentators be respectful and courteous. Instead, a public body may set restrictions on reasonable time, place, and manner comments to ensure that the meeting retains an orderly and peaceable manner.